Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,155,934 members, 7,828,259 topics. Date: Wednesday, 15 May 2024 at 07:24 AM

Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? - Religion - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? (2293 Views)

LADIES IF YOU GO TO HELL AFTER READING THIS THEN YOU HAVE YOURSELF TO BLAME / Woman Gets A Glimpse Of Hell After Suicide Attempt / Did Jesus Descend Into Hell? (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 11:05pm On Nov 10, 2012
In the Apostles' Creed, there is a statement about Jesus descending into hell. Did he literally go there?—DEBRA BLACK, Alton, IllinoisEach Sunday, millions of Christians around the world recite the Apostles' Creed, including that statement:
"I believe that Jesus … descended into hell."

Yet a few years back at one Christian college, a series of chapel messages on the Apostles' Creed had to omit this item, because none of the 12 professors of Bible and theology believed it.

Actually the statement is not found in the earliest form of the Apostles' Creed. It echoes Acts 2:31, and seems to be there simply to make the point that Jesus' death was real and complete. Jesus went to hades, which in the Greek signifies the world of the departed—paradise for some, pain for others. When the Apostles' Creed took its English form in the sixteenth century, "hell" meant hades as such, rather than the final state of the lost (which Jesus called gehenna), as it always is today. So, should those who accept the Bible as their supreme authority for belief hold to the Creed's doctrine on this point?

Scripture tells us very little about Jesus' state between his death and resurrection. The most commonly cited biblical passages are Acts 2:31 ; Ephesians 4:8-10 ; 1 Peter 4:6; and, most importantly, 1 Peter 3:18-20. Ephesians 4 is likely a reference to the Incarnation, and 1 Peter 4:6 could apply to any preaching of the gospel. But numerous interpretations of 1 Peter 3:18-20 exist. Some say the 1 Peter 3 passage should not be taken literally—that it is symbolic, conveying in graphic form the idea that redemption is universal in its extent. This, however, involves a more spiritualized hermeneutic than usually practiced by evangelicals.
Others contend that this refers to a descent by Jesus into the realm of the dead between his death and resurrection, and an actual preaching to its occupants, either offering salvation to them or declaring his own triumph over death and judgment upon those who in their earthly life did not respond to God. This interpretation, however, seems in conflict with the rest of Jesus' life and ministry—and with the context of the passage, which emphasizes a faithful, gentle witness, giving a reason for one's faith, even in the face of opposition .

At the same time, the non-literal interpretation has difficulty accounting adequately for the reference to Noah , unless the preaching was restricted only to people from Noah's time, which seems strange. It also appears to conflict with the theological context, or how our interpretation fits with other, more clearly established doctrines. Here we encounter biblical references teaching the finality of death over and against any opportunity for salvation, at least since the time of Christ.

Many consider the parable of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) pertinent to the question, as are much of Psalm 49 and Revelation 20:11-15. Hebrews 9:27 indicates a close linkage between death and judgment, with nothing mentioned as intervening. And Jesus' statement to the thief on the cross—"today you will be with me in paradise" (Luke 23:42,43)—also is relevant.

One other interpretation, held by Augustine and defended strongly by several evangelicals, seems more promising. In this view, Christ preached "in spirit" through Noah as Noah built the ark. This was a message of repentance and righteousness, given to unbelieving people who were then on earth but now are "spirits in prison" (i.e., in hell).

Source: http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2000/february7/31.74.html
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Nobody: 11:12am On Nov 11, 2012
Christ definitely descended to the realm of the dead to preach to those who died in noah's flood.although the word prison was used to describe where they were being held some have likened it to purgatory in view of the fact that hell is a place of eternal damnation which should not warrant Jesus going there to preach to anyone
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Ubenedictus(m): 11:37am On Nov 11, 2012
pastormustwacc: In the Apostles' Creed, there is a statement about Jesus descending into hell. Did he literally go there?—DEBRA BLACK, Alton, IllinoisEach Sunday, millions of Christians around the world recite the Apostles' Creed, including that statement:
"I believe that Jesus … descended into hell."

Yet a few years back at one Christian college, a series of chapel messages on the Apostles' Creed had to omit this item, because none of the 12 professors of Bible and theology believed it.

Actually the statement is not found in the earliest form of the Apostles' Creed. It echoes Acts 2:31, and seems to be there simply to make the point that Jesus' death was real and complete. Jesus went to hades, which in the Greek signifies the world of the departed—paradise for some, pain for others. When the Apostles' Creed took its English form in the sixteenth century, "hell" meant hades as such, rather than the final state of the lost (which Jesus called gehenna), as it always is today. So, should those who accept the Bible as their supreme authority for belief hold to the Creed's doctrine on this point?

Scripture tells us very little about Jesus' state between his death and resurrection. The most commonly cited biblical passages are Acts 2:31 ; Ephesians 4:8-10 ; 1 Peter 4:6; and, most importantly, 1 Peter 3:18-20. Ephesians 4 is likely a reference to the Incarnation, and 1 Peter 4:6 could apply to any preaching of the gospel. But numerous interpretations of 1 Peter 3:18-20 exist. Some say the 1 Peter 3 passage should not be taken literally—that it is symbolic, conveying in graphic form the idea that redemption is universal in its extent. This, however, involves a more spiritualized hermeneutic than usually practiced by evangelicals.
Others contend that this refers to a descent by Jesus into the realm of the dead between his death and resurrection, and an actual preaching to its occupants, either offering salvation to them or declaring his own triumph over death and judgment upon those who in their earthly life did not respond to God. This interpretation, however, seems in conflict with the rest of Jesus' life and ministry—and with the context of the passage, which emphasizes a faithful, gentle witness, giving a reason for one's faith, even in the face of opposition .

At the same time, the non-literal interpretation has difficulty accounting adequately for the reference to Noah , unless the preaching was restricted only to people from Noah's time, which seems strange. It also appears to conflict with the theological context, or how our interpretation fits with other, more clearly established doctrines. Here we encounter biblical references teaching the finality of death over and against any opportunity for salvation, at least since the time of Christ.

Many consider the parable of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) pertinent to the question, as are much of Psalm 49 and Revelation 20:11-15. Hebrews 9:27 indicates a close linkage between death and judgment, with nothing mentioned as intervening. And Jesus' statement to the thief on the cross—"today you will be with me in paradise" (Luke 23:42,43)—also is relevant.

One other interpretation, held by Augustine and defended strongly by several evangelicals, seems more promising. In this view, Christ preached "in spirit" through Noah as Noah built the ark. This was a message of repentance and righteousness, given to unbelieving people who were then on earth but now are "spirits in prison" (i.e., in hell).

Source: http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2000/february7/31.74.html
it seems u have suceeded in confusing urself.
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 2:25am On Nov 12, 2012
This is interesting, but i really wonder the person that is really confused.
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Ubenedictus(m): 6:34am On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc: This is interesting, but i really wonder the person that is really confused.
u found a cunny way to escape d literal interpretation, personally i dont see anything against scripture in d literal interpretation. So why are u looking 4 an alternative?
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Joagbaje(m): 7:09am On Nov 12, 2012
Yes Jesus descended into hell. He preached to souls in hell. He set captives free in hell. Those who were held in hell against their wishes. Righteous men of old
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 7:21am On Nov 12, 2012
Joagbaje: Yes Jesus descended into hell. He preached to souls in hell. He set captives free in hell. Those who were held in hell against their wishes. Righteous men of old

Which captives??........

So the deluge that destroyed the wicked during noahs was just a joke??....

Which spirits did Jesus preach to??
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 8:25am On Nov 12, 2012
Na wa o, i still need bible to tell us when he descended to hell. So the righteous souls have been suffering in hell all these years before jesus came to preach to them?
whatever happpened to - after death is judgement? o no, it is purgatory before judgement?
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 9:12am On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc: Na wa o, i still need bible to tell us when he descended to hell. So the righteous souls have been suffering in hell all these years before jesus came to preach to them?
whatever happpened to - after death is judgement? o no, it is purgatory before judgement?

Those spirits who were in prison that Jesus preached to were the ""angels"" who were disobedient during noahs day....

Those spirits were not the souls of righteous individuals.......

Those spirits were spirits(angels)..........

Let us remember that when a human dies,his or her spirit(breath of life ) returns to God and does not go somewhere else in a pit to live.....

Try comparing 1 peter 3:18-20 with 2 peter 2:4 and also jude 6....

Jude 6..
New Living Translation (©2007)
And I remind you of the angels who did not
stay within the limits of authority God gave
them but left the place where they belonged.
God has kept them ""securely chained in prisons""
of darkness, waiting for the great day of
judgment.
_______________________________

2 peter 2:4...
Young's Literal Translation
For if God messengers who sinned did not
spare, but with ""chains"" of thick gloom, having
cast them down to"" Tartarus"", did deliver them
to judgment, having been reserved,






Tarturus is a place meant for disobedient angels and not humans...........



Only 8 souls survived the deluge,while the rest humans died and ceased to exist.......

Thank you.......
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 9:51am On Nov 12, 2012
ijawkid:

Those spirits who were in prison that Jesus preached to were the ""angels"" who were disobedient during noahs day....

Those spirits were not the souls of righteous individuals.......

Those spirits were spirits(angels)..........

Let us remember that when a human dies,his or her spirit(breath of life ) returns to God and does not go somewhere else in a pit to live.....

Try comparing 1 peter 3:18-20 with 2 peter 2:4 and also jude 6....

Jude 6..
New Living Translation (©2007)
And I remind you of the angels who did not
stay within the limits of authority God gave
them but left the place where they belonged.
God has kept them ""securely chained in prisons""
of darkness, waiting for the great day of
judgment.
_______________________________

2 peter 2:4...
Young's Literal Translation
For if God messengers who sinned did not
spare, but with ""chains"" of thick gloom, having
cast them down to"" Tartarus"", did deliver them
to judgment, having been reserved,






Tarturus is a place meant for disobedient angels and not humans...........



Only 8 souls survived the deluge,while the rest humans died and ceased to exist.......

Thank you.......

And i shall cancel all that one with one single scripture

1 Corinthians 6:3
Do you not know that we will judge angels? How much more the things of this life!

Now if jesus has set free those angels that sinned, that one na to mean say na only satan will go to hell, no angels left for us to judge. Oya talk another one.
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 10:37am On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc:

And i shall cancel all that one with one single scripture

1 Corinthians 6:3


Now if jesus has set free those angels that sinned, that one na to mean say na only satan will go to hell, no angels left for us to judge. Oya talk another one.

Did those verses say Jesus set free those spirits who were in prison??...

Is that what the scriptures said??.......

Those scriptures quoted shows they were kept in prison until the great day of judgement......

Jesus didn't release any spirit from Hell.....

Abi your own bible tell you like that??....
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 11:36am On Nov 12, 2012
^^^You did not read my post properly be that. Anyway, we are derailing the thread.
So you believe Jesus descended to hell?
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 11:49am On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc: ^^^You did not read my post properly be that. Anyway, we are derailing the thread.
So you believe Jesus descended to hell?

I did read your post....I was just trying to clarify the part where many think those ""spirits"" in tartarus are souls of dead humans.....

____________________________

Accoring to 1 peter 3:18-20 Jesus did go to the spirits in ""prison"" after his ressurection......

""AFTER HIS RESSURECTION"""
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 3:02pm On Nov 12, 2012
^^^But were the imprisoned spirits in hell
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 3:17pm On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc: ^^^But were the imprisoned spirits in hell

Now there are many definitions of HELL.....

Na tartarus you dey talk about??
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Delafruita(m): 3:35pm On Nov 12, 2012
ijawkid:

Now there are many definitions of HELL.....

Na tartarus you dey talk about??
christianity:epitome of confusion
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Joagbaje(m): 5:21pm On Nov 12, 2012
ijawkid:

Which captives??........

So the deluge that destroyed the wicked during noahs was just a joke??....

Which spirits did Jesus preach to??

1 Peter 3:18-19
For Christ also hath once suffered for sins, the just for the unjust, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh, but quickened by the Spirit: 19 By which also he went and preached unto the spirits in prison;
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Nobody: 6:35pm On Nov 12, 2012
1 Peter 3:18-20

English Standard Version (ESV)

18 For Christ also suffered[a] once for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit, 19 in which[b] he went and proclaimed[c] to the spirits in prison, [b]20 because[d] they formerly did not obey, when God's patience waited in the days of Noah, while the ark was being prepared, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were brought safely through water.[\b]

It is clearly stated that these were souls of men who perished in noah's flood yet people are here spewing rubbish
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 6:45pm On Nov 12, 2012
chukwudi44: 1 Peter 3:18-20

English Standard Version (ESV)

18 For Christ also suffered[a] once for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, that he might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit, 19 in which[b] he went and proclaimed[c] to the spirits in prison, [b]20 because[d] they formerly did not obey, when God's patience waited in the days of Noah, while the ark was being prepared, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were brought safely through water.[\b]

It is clearly stated that these were souls of men who perished in noah's flood yet people are here spewing rubbish

Did that scripture mention souls or spirits??...

Mr chukwudi........

The other scriptures quoted proves those were the disobedient angels who left there lofty position and sinned against God.....

God has locked no"" soul"" in any prison....

You dey hear me??...

When we die we stay in our graves awaiting ressurection........

Did that scripture tell you that those spirits were the souls of those who perished during the deluge??....

Na purgatory dey cause this your conclusion o......

1 Like

Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 7:17pm On Nov 12, 2012
Kai, them don confuse me sef on this thread.

*Sweating profusely after reading posts*
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 7:30pm On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc: Kai, them don confuse me sef on this thread.

*Sweating profusely after reading posts*

Lwkmd.....

Chei you no go kill me with laugh........

come take handkerchief.....
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 8:17pm On Nov 12, 2012
Faints due to total dehydration from profuse sweating

*Wakes up and crawls out of the thread*
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by ijawkid(m): 9:01pm On Nov 12, 2012
pastormustwacc: Faints due to total dehydration from profuse sweating

*Wakes up and crawls out of the thread*

Lmao.....

Pastormustwac you are too funny....

You must finish this thread today.......lol....
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Nobody: 9:07pm On Nov 12, 2012
chukwudi44: Christ definitely descended to the realm of the dead to preach to those who died in noah's flood.although the word prison was used to describe where they were being held some have likened it to purgatory in view of the fact that hell is a place of eternal damnation which should not warrant Jesus going there to preach to anyone

Wrong !!

Jesus descended to the grave and was DEAD !!!

God then raised him up from the dead on the third day , which is why he is called the first-born from the dead , as an example of the mass resurrection of the saints at the last trump.

It is very amazing and even mysterious that many people hold the same pagan beliefs as Catholics.

1 Like

Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 10:22pm On Nov 12, 2012
Wakes up in the valley of dry bones after ministrations by frosbel.
frosbel:
Wrong !!

Jesus descended to the grave and was DEAD !!!

God then raised him up from the dead on the third day , which is why he is called the first-born from the dead , as an example of the mass resurrection of the saints at the last trump.

It is very amazing and even mysterious that many people hold the same pagan beliefs as Catholics.
Now this has turned into wrestling with two players:
Frosbel: weighing 500 pounds, with 500 wins and 0 defeats,
versus
chukwudi44: weighing only 25 pounds, with 0 wins and 419 defeats

We must to see the winner!!

1 Like

Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Ubenedictus(m): 1:53am On Nov 15, 2012
pastormustwacc: Wakes up in the valley of dry bones after ministrations by frosbel.

Now this has turned into wrestling with two players:
Frosbel: weighing 500 pounds, with 500 wins and 0 defeats,
versus
chukwudi44: weighing only 25 pounds, with 0 wins and 419 defeats

We must to see the winner!!
this does sound insultive!
D apostles creed say "he descended into hell", hell is actually "hades" or "shoel", it has nothing to do with d abode of d damned. What shoel and hades actually mean is an arguement 4 another day.
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by pastormustwacc: 6:32am On Nov 15, 2012
^^^Not meant to be that way, it is just interesting how everyone always pick their sides when it comes to some things.
Re: Did Jesus Really Descend To Hell After Death According To The Apostles Creed? by Ubenedictus(m): 2:46pm On Nov 15, 2012
pastormustwacc: ^^^Not meant to be that way, it is just interesting how everyone always pick their sides when it comes to some things.
i heard they say "Religion makes strange bed fellows"

(1) (Reply)

Thanks, Seun! The Religion Section Is Now Officially Boring. / 10 Extremely Weird Religions / PROPHECY: Dr. Paul Enenche Of Dunamis Reveals What Will Happen In 2016

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 80
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.