ANALYSIS OF RESULTS FROM 11 FOCAL STATES

Analysis of Votes/Results obtained as reflected in Certified True Copies of Forms EC84, FM and EC8C from the 11 focal States, namely:

Kaduna, Katsina, Kebbi, Kano, Bauchi, Born, Gombe, figawa, Niger, Yohbe and Zamfara States as pleaded in Paragraph 113 to 363 of the Petition.

The 1st Respondent wrongly and unlawfully credited the 2nd Respondent with votes which were not valid or lawful in the above listed focal States at the election, namely, at the polling units, the ward collating centres, local government collating centre.

The results of the election as announced by the 1st Respondent and especially the votes credited to the 2nd Respondent do not represent the lawful votes cast.

The scores credited the 2nd Respondent were not the products of actual votes validly cast at the polling units.

From the above, it is clear that the collated results as contained in the tendered Certified True Copies of Forms EC84 from the polling units are irreconcilably different from the electronically collated results that were transmitted or inputted to the 1st Respondent's Server from the Smart Card Reader deployed by the 1st Respondent for the purpose of accreditation of voters and transmission of results to the 1st Respondent's Central Server.

Even so, the Petitioners went on to establish that based on the lawful votes from the Manual Collations, the Petitioners still scored the majority of lawful votes cast.

The Petitioners called PW60 who is a statistician and an expert whose reports were admitted as Exhibits P90A-K being the analysis of exhibits:
PNG1 - PNG3464 (Niger State);
PYB1 - PYB1731 (Yobe State);
PKT1 - PKT 3377 (Katsina State);
PKB1 - PKB2105 (Kebbi State);
PB01 - PB03471 (Bor. State):
P551 - PIG 3161 (figawa State);
PGB1 - PGB 1911 (Gombe State);
PBC1 - PBC 3598 (Bauchi State);
PKD1 - PKD3334 (Kaduna State);
PKN1 - PKN 7159 (Kano State) AND
PM -PZF1000 (Zanfara State).


4.44 These reports (P90A-K) are unchallenged and remained so as none of the Respondents controverted the detailed analysis of unlawful votes extracted from Exhibits PNG1 • PNG3464; PYB1 - PYB1731; PIM - PKT 3377; PKB1 - PKB2105; PB01 -